A team formed by founding members of Trust Legal Alliance, namely av. Dragoș Nicolescu (Dean of the Argeș Bar), together with av. Remus Sas, av. Anca Moisiuc and av. Paul Vargan (all from Vargan & Vargan – Civil Law Society), brought together their skills in a collaboration that led to a favorable solution for Compact Lacoli S.R.L.: The Argeș Court ordered the suspension of the forced execution initiated by ANAF against the company.
The appeal court admitted the appeal and completely changed the decision of the first instance, which had rejected the request. Thus, the forced execution remains suspended until the substantive resolution of the enforcement challenge. The conclusions in the appeal were supported by av. Dragoș Nicolescu.
The solution is of particular interest for tax practice. The suspension was obtained under common law, namely art. 719 C.proc.civ., although the request for suspension of the execution of the administrative-fiscal act formulated according to art. 14 of Law no. 554/2004 was rejected. The first instance retained this rejection as a decisive argument against the suspension of the forced execution. In the appeal, however, the distinction between the two legal mechanisms, which have distinct conditions and purposes, was capitalized on.
“Sometimes, in judicial practice, miracles happen that “fracture” the law in order to do justice. All you need is the perseverance of lawyers and the “light” of a judge who understands that the truth is made up of layers that are not always found in the text of the law, but in its spirit.” – av. Remus Sas.
Beyond the legal particularities of the case, the solution illustrates an essential reality: the hypothesis of a legal norm is, by its nature, general and cannot capture the entire diversity of concrete situations. Therefore, the application of the law involves more than the mechanical confrontation of texts. In this case, the perseverance of the team of lawyers met the openness of the appeal court to examine each layer of the legal problem and to distinguish between two remedies that, although close in appearance, are not confused.
“In the appeal, we managed to outline the very fine distinction between the “sound reasons” of art. 719 of the Civil Procedure Code and the “well-justified case”, together with the “imminent damage”, within the meaning of art. 2 and 14 of Law no. 554/2004. The rejection of the request to suspend the administrative-fiscal act could not determine, by itself, the solution to the suspension of the forced execution. It is precisely the diversity of particular situations that requires an interpretation that does not lose sight of the spirit of the law.”, concluded lawyer Remus Sas.




