On the human dimension behind the law. An intern’s vision

1. The role of psychology in the beginning of a career

In the first months of practice, the attention of a trainee lawyer is seized by adapting to the new team, assimilating procedures, rigorously drafting documents and mastering the rules of the court. However, everyday reality reveals a much more complex dynamic: beyond files, we manage people. The client is not just an accumulation of legal facts, but an emotional universe marked by crisis, uncertainty and vulnerability. And from the perspective of a young professional, understanding the human psyche becomes as important as mastering legal norms.

Entering the profession brings with it the realization that the legal universe is not limited to the mechanical application of legal norms; each case hides behind a human drama, a state of tension or an acute need for security. The trainee lawyer, at the intersection between university theory and the harsh reality of practice, quickly discovers that managing the relationship with the client represents half the success of a representation strategy. Therefore, deciphering the psychology of the litigant becomes a fundamental competence in becoming a professional, an indispensable working tool for building a solid career.

2. Active listening as a therapeutic and legal tool

In any interpersonal relationship, but even more so in the legal profession, active listening is the foundation of trust. The client walks into the lawyer’s office carrying the burden of a problem that affects his patrimonial, family or personal life. He is, most of the time, in a state of heightened psychological vulnerability, looking not only for a legal specialist, but for a moral ally. In this phase, he needs emotional validation, before technical analyses, it is the moment when we must unblock the lawyer-client connection.

An essential practice that I consider vital at the beginning of a career, and not only, is the rule of the first 15 minutes.[1] This involves letting the client freely tell his story, without methodological interruptions, premature legal corrections or manifestations of impatience on the part of the lawyer. During this interval, the foundations of the entire future collaboration are laid. The client has the opportunity to unload his emotional baggage, to feel validated and respected.

From a psychological point of view, this fifteen minutes produces remarkable effects. First of all, a space of psychological safety and emotional comfort is created. Although the framework remains strictly professional and rigorous, the client relaxes and gains trust, noticing that the lawyer’s attention is fully dedicated to him. The lawyer leads the discussion, maintaining the objectivity of the conversation, clear boundaries, contact method, available hours and such details.[2]

Second, through active listening, the lawyer obtains not only raw facts but also valuable clues about the client’s inner motivations, fears, and values. This approach transforms listening from a simple form of politeness into a necessity that will only bring benefits, because a client who feels listened to, not just heard, will be more cooperative, more honest, more malleable.

3. There are not only “difficult clients”, but also situations that produce difficult behaviors

Most people come to a lawyer looking for absolute certainty, an anchor in a moment when they are wavering; they do not just want a hypothetical legal strategy or a nuanced analysis of legal texts. I have noticed from the first interactions that they want a firm promise of resolution, they want certainty and predictability. Therefore, most may tend to believe that in a single session they will find a solution that will guarantee their success.

From a psychological perspective[3], the client feels the need to be assured that the outcome will be favorable, practically wanting to transfer all of his anxiety and responsibility onto the lawyer’s shoulders. At the beginning of the consultation, there is the unknown, anxiety, fear of financial loss (“what if I go to lawyer X and they don’t solve anything?”), these are the main states that dominate their behavior, and depending on them we can also identify the client’s typology. There are anxious clients, who need continuous information, the category of people for whom constant information and details create security. There are aggressive clients; they rely on pride or anger, instincts that are actually harder to control when the situation seems to be overwhelming them. A category of negligent clients can be identified, those who are always late, omit details, forget documents, etc., but also the category of insincere clients, a category that can even encompass others. This typology almost never represents a manifestation of malice, but a form of self-defense. Of course, understanding the possible causes of a behavior does not mean tolerating all behavior. Respect must be mutual. The lawyer can show patience and, at the same time, establish clear rules for communication, transmission of documents and the professional relationship.

Beyond the file and the raw facts, the trainee lawyer discovers a human typology, guided by a complex emotional dynamic, a paralyzing fear of being judged and a burning desire to preserve his innocence, if only in the eyes of his defense attorney. When a client knowingly or unknowingly hides the truth, he not only sabotages the legal strategy, but in reality cries out for validation.

This defensive state often finds its roots in a dynamic of shame. As psychiatrist Irvin Yalom explains in his works[4], man tends to hide his greatest vulnerabilities precisely from the one from whom he expects salvation, for fear of abandonment or rejection. The insincere client builds a wall because he fears that once the truth is revealed, the lawyer will lose enthusiasm for defending him or will look down on him.

In the same vein, in his book, “Judicial Psychology”, the Romanian author Nicolae Mitrofan [5] emphasizes that “dishonesty” in the context of interrogation or hearing is not always bad faith, but can be an adaptation mechanism to the traumatic stress of the trial; the client rewrites reality not to deceive the justice system, but to psychologically survive in the face of his own conscience.

Here comes one of the first and most difficult ethical and psychological dilemmas of the trainee lawyer. How can we manage the client’s desperate need for reassurance without violating the obligation of means specific to the profession? It is tempting, especially at the beginning, out of a desire to sign the legal assistance contract or to impress, to offer certainties that the law or the unpredictability of the courts do not support. However, psychological honesty is the only sustainable path. You can provide moral support, guarantee high-quality and professional representation, and even rely on good collaboration and communication.

People compulsively seek, when they have problems, magical solutions and comforting promises. Our duty, as young lawyers, is to subtly dismantle these illusions, offering them clarity, realism, and solid strategies instead. We must learn to offer them security through the quality of our training, not through ephemeral promises. Educating the client in the spirit of understanding the procedural risks is a test of professional maturity, while also preventing the degradation of the legal relationship in the event of an unfavorable outcome.[6]

4. The power of modern communication or years of experience?

In the collective public perception there is a behavioral automatism, considerable seniority in the profession is directly assimilated with infallibility. When a client hears that a lawyer has “20 years of experience”, he feels an immediate psychological security, a feeling of protection quickly appears. However, years of seniority do not automatically guarantee universal competence.

A senior lawyer may have a narrow or even niche area of ​​practice, facing limited diversity, despite the past decades. Also, in some cases, the routine accumulated over the years can reduce enthusiasm or attention to detail. Therefore, experience brings a strong psychological security to the client, but not necessarily a real one in relation to his specific case.

In contrast, the lack of experience of a trainee can be compensated by exceptional communication and enthusiasm. A lawyer at the beginning of his career has a major advantage, the full willingness to invest time, attention and energy in studying the file. The ability to be present in the conversation, to earn his merit, to deserve the appreciation and the place in the client’s mind, make the intern a hyper-attentive person. Where a senior allocates only a few minutes due to the large workload, the intern tends to analyze every detail.

Moreover, we quickly noticed that the dynamics imposed new communication standards: a simple periodic update sent via a short message, a messaging platform or a quick email has a positive impact on the litigant. For the client, this signal eliminates the feeling of abandonment and shows proactivity.

Empathetic and transparent communication is not intended to offer the client a comfortable illusion of control, but to anchor them in reality, but supported. As the process progresses, the lawyer’s willingness to openly explain the risks and the legal action plan offers the client an essential time frame, a space of accommodation in which the initial suspicion diminishes and paves the way for trust. The client will see beyond the profession and will observe in real time the perseverance, the nights of study and the involvement of his or her lawyer. This partnership has a beneficial impact, and in the event of an unfavorable outcome, the court’s solution becomes much easier to accept. The client will not feel abandoned or wronged by his own defense attorney, because he has witnessed the effort and loyalty demonstrated throughout the judicial process.

Conclusion

Analysis of the client’s psychology is not a mere accessory to legal practice, but is the very heart of the legal profession. The success of a trainee lawyer will not be measured in the long term only by the number of litigations won, but also by the profound ability to manage the human relationships behind those litigations.

Obviously, it should be noted that there is a fine line between understanding a person’s suffering and adopting their perspective without reservations. A lawyer who identifies too much with the client’s indignation risks losing the distance necessary for objective assessment, transforming a legal conflict into a personal one, or recommending steps that are more emotionally satisfying than legally useful. Independence does not operate only in relation to the courts, authorities, or the opposing party. It must be preserved, when necessary, also in relation to one’s own client.

Saying “no” to an unfounded approach does not mean a lack of empathy. On the contrary, it can be the most responsible expression of professional loyalty. In the legal profession, client care is not measured by the number of requests accepted, but also by the quality of those justifiably discouraged.

By cultivating active listening, by refusing to fall into the trap of easy promises, and by implementing a proactive and empathetic communication model, the young lawyer can transform an often difficult legal experience for the litigant into a partnership based on dignity, respect, and total transparency. From this perspective, the internship is not only a period of knowledge accumulation, but also a school of humanity and psychological maturation.

[1] Client Science: Advice for Lawyers on Initial Client Interviews, 2013, Marjorie Corman Aaron University of Cincinnati College of Law, aaronmc@uc.edu,
[2] Groza, Gabriela – Psychology applied in criminal proceedings, Universul Juridic Publishing House, Bucharest, 2020.
[3] Butoi, Tudorel; Butoi, Ioana-Teodora – University Treatise on Forensic Psychology, Phobos Publishing House, Bucharest.
[4] Yalom, Irvin – The Executioner of Love and Other Stories of Psychotherapy, Humanitas Publishing House, Bucharest, 2008.
[5] Mitrofan, Nicolae; Zdrenghea, Voicu; Butoi, Tudorel – Forensic Psychology, Sansa Publishing House and Press, Bucharest.
[6] Rogers, Carl – Becoming a Person. Perspective of a Psychotherapist, Trei Publishing House, Bucharest, 2025.

Trainee lawyer Camelia Curea, Vargan and Vargan – Civil Law Firm

Share

Leave a Reply